by Traverse Legal, reviewed by Enrico Schaefer - August 17, 2026 - Airbnb
A guest wrecked something in your rental. You filed under AirCover, sent the photos, the estimates, and the receipts, and then nothing happened. Airbnb asks for documents you already sent, goes quiet, misses its own deadlines, and never pays. It also never issues a real denial. You are not imagining the pattern, and you are not without options.
Host Damage Protection is the part of AirCover for Hosts that reimburses you for guest-caused damage, up to $3 million, when the guest will not pay. Airbnb states plainly that it is not insurance. It is a contractual reimbursement program governed by Airbnb’s Terms of Service, which means your rights come from that contract, not from state insurance law.
That distinction matters more than most hosts realize. There is no state insurance commissioner to appeal to. The automatic bad-faith remedies that apply to insurers do not apply the same way to a platform running its own reimbursement program. Airbnb keeps discretion over whether to approve a claim and how much to pay, it commonly pays depreciated value rather than full replacement cost, and it requires you to seek payment from the responsible guest before the program applies.
Claims get denied or reduced for a handful of reasons: missing documentation, a dispute over whether the guest actually caused the damage, depreciation applied to the payout, or an exclusion like ordinary wear and tear. Those are decisions you can respond to. The harder cases are the ones with no decision at all.
In a stalled claim, Airbnb requests the same records more than once, transfers the file from one team to another and resets the clock, promises follow-up within a set number of hours and lets the deadline pass, and escalates its demands over time: more photos, then a video walkthrough, then forensic accounting and bank statements, all after the receipts were already sent. The claim never gets paid and never gets formally denied.
A denial is a decision you can appeal or challenge. A stall is not. When Airbnb neither pays nor denies for months, it avoids creating a reviewable decision while running out your patience. Hosts read that as a dead end. It is closer to the opposite.
Every repeated request, missed deadline, and week of silence is documentable, and once documented it stops being an obstacle and becomes evidence. A pattern of avoiding a decision, rather than making one, supports a breach-of-contract claim and a claim that Airbnb failed to deal with you in good faith. Save the message history in full. It is the strongest part of most of these files.
Airbnb’s Terms of Service contain a clause limiting Airbnb’s total liability to a host, often tied to what Airbnb paid that host over a prior period. Whether that cap reaches a Host Damage Protection claim depends on the exact wording and on the version of the Terms in force when your loss happened. Read it before you assume it controls your claim.
Two points do real work here. First, some versions of the Terms carve damage-protection payments out of the cap, which can place your core property-damage claim outside it entirely. Second, Airbnb sometimes relies on a version of the Terms that post-dates the loss; the operative contract is the one in effect when the damage occurred, and it is worth confirming which version that is. Where a platform tries to use a liability cap to excuse its own claims handling, counsel also raise unconscionability under California Civil Code section 1670.5, on the theory that a clause capping a company’s exposure for its own bad conduct at the revenue it already collected functions as an immunity, not a limitation.
Usually yes. Airbnb’s Terms choose California law to govern disputes arising from them, regardless of where you or your property sit. That is good news, because California gives hosts theories that many home states do not.
California reads an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing into every contract, which is the natural home for a stalled-claim case. The Unfair Competition Law, Business and Professions Code section 17200, reaches unfair or fraudulent business practices and allows restitution. The Consumers Legal Remedies Act, Civil Code section 1750 and following, can add damages and attorney’s fees, though whether a host running a short-term rental qualifies as a “consumer” under section 1761 is a genuine fight and turns on the facts of how you operate. None of these is automatic. All of them are worth evaluating before you settle for a depreciated offer or walk away.
Push back in writing, escalate, then use the dispute-resolution process the Terms require. The path runs roughly like this:
One caution on court. Airbnb’s Terms require most host disputes to go to arbitration, not to court, and they waive class actions. Individual arbitration is typically the only forum available, so the demand you file there is the case.
Look for counsel who represent hosts against the platform rather than run brand-side or guest-side enforcement, who treat these as contract and consumer-protection claims under California law, and who have actually filed and argued AAA arbitrations against Airbnb rather than only sending demand letters. Ask how many Airbnb arbitrations the lawyer has taken through the process, and whether they handle the liability-cap and Terms-version issues as a matter of course. Those two issues decide more of these cases than the damage numbers do.
Traverse Attorneys & Advisors represents short-term-rental hosts in AirCover and Host Damage Protection disputes, wrongful deactivations, frozen payouts, and cancelled-reservation losses, and files them as arbitrations under Airbnb’s Terms of Service. Founding partner Enrico Schaefer has prosecuted more than 500 arbitration cases against Airbnb on behalf of hosts, and over two decades the firm has recovered multi-million-dollar awards and settlements for hosts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome, and every case turns on its own facts.
A typical host matter starts where this article does: a documented claim the platform will not pay and will not formally deny. The work is to reframe it as enforcement of Airbnb’s own contractual promise to pay for guest damage, to place the core property damage outside any liability cap, and to add the good-faith and California consumer-protection claims that reach the cost of the runaround itself.
Is AirCover the same as insurance?
No. Airbnb states that Host Damage Protection is not an insurance policy. It is a contractual reimbursement program under Airbnb’s Terms of Service, so your remedies come from contract and consumer-protection law rather than state insurance law, and there is no insurance commissioner to appeal to.
How long do I have to file an Airbnb damage claim?
You generally must file in the Resolution Center and submit supporting documentation within 14 days of the guest’s checkout or the damage. Miss that window and Airbnb can deny the claim on timing alone, so document the damage and file quickly.
Can I sue Airbnb in court over a denied damage claim?
Usually not. Airbnb’s Terms require most host disputes to go to arbitration before the American Arbitration Association after a 30-day pre-dispute notice, and they waive class actions. Individual arbitration is typically the only path.
Does Airbnb pay full replacement cost?
Often not. Host Damage Protection commonly pays depreciated value, and Airbnb retains discretion over approval and amount. Proof of purchase and replacement cost helps you challenge a depreciated offer, especially for items that should not depreciate, like flooring or recently bought appliances.
What if Airbnb never denies my claim but never pays?
Document every request, deadline, and silence. A pattern of stalling instead of deciding can support a breach-of-contract and good-faith claim under California law, and it is often stronger evidence than a clean denial would have been.
Which state’s law governs my Airbnb dispute?
Airbnb’s Terms choose California law regardless of where you live. That generally gives you California contract and consumer-protection theories, including the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing that California reads into every contract.
How much does it cost to arbitrate against Airbnb?
As of 2026, host disputes run under AAA rules with a consumer filing fee of roughly $225. The consumer fee schedule shifts most of the arbitrator and administrative costs to the business rather than the individual, though the exact allocation depends on the rules in effect.
Do I have to try to collect from the guest first?
Yes. Airbnb requires hosts to seek reimbursement from the responsible guest before Host Damage Protection applies. The guest has 24 hours to respond to your Resolution Center request before Airbnb steps in to review it.
Enrico Schaefer
Traverse, Attorneys and Advisors
enrico.schaefer@traverselegal.com
www.traverselegal.com
This article is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Airbnb’s programs, terms, and dispute procedures change; confirm the current terms and the version in force at the time of your loss. This page is attorney advertising.
As a founding partner of Traverse Legal, PLC, he has more than thirty years of experience as an attorney for both established companies and emerging start-ups. His extensive experience includes navigating technology law matters and complex litigation throughout the United States.
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorney Enrico Schaefer, who has more than 20 years of legal experience as a practicing Business, IP, and Technology Law litigation attorney.